2018 NRL Side

[Taylor1921]

He weighs the same as McGuire but is 8cms taller than him. He's more of a prop than McGuire is.

Just because you weight more than a prop doesn't mean you are a prop, he has never worn a 8 or 10 jumper. He is a second rower/lock don't be dumb.

 

[Taylor1921]

He weighs the same as McGuire but is 8cms taller than him. He's more of a prop than McGuire is.

Corey Oates is 15cm taller than McGuire and weighs a few more kms, does that mean he should start at prop for the broncos next year. See what your saying doesn't make sense.

 

[Porthoz]

If he pulls his shit out. He's been rather underwhelming

The best Broncos prop in the second half of the season, and the youngest, but yeah... underwhelming, let's go with that.

 

[BroncsFan]

Just because you weight more than a prop doesn't mean you are a prop, he has never worn a 8 or 10 jumper. He is a second rower/lock don't be dumb.

He played prop for bulldogs

 

[upthebroncs]

Just because you weight more than a prop doesn't mean you are a prop, he has never worn a 8 or 10 jumper. He is a second rower/lock don't be dumb.

I think it's more dumb to say he's not a prop by calling him a lock instead.. He's playing the same role as the props in the side. Same role, different name

 

[upthebroncs]

Corey Oates is 15cm taller than McGuire and weighs a few more kms, does that mean he should start at prop for the broncos next year. See what your saying doesn't make sense.

We're talking about Finucane (Lock), not Oates (Winger)..

So what you're saying is not relevant.

 

[Taylor1921]

We're talking about Finucane (Lock), not Oates (Winger)..
So what you're saying is not relevant.

Did you not just say Finucane was taller and heavier so he is more of prop than McGuire.

 

[Taylor1921]

He played prop for bulldogs

No he did not, he was off the bench majority or at lock. Tolman, Kasiano and Graham were the props.

 

[Taylor1921]

I think it's more dumb to say he's not a prop by calling him a lock instead.. He's playing the same role as the props in the side. Same role, different name

Anyone who thinks lock is the same as a prop has no clue.

 

[upthebroncs]

Did you not just say Finucane was taller and heavier so he is more of prop than McGuire.

He plays in the middle every week as a lock.

He is built like a middle forward.

He is tall enough and heavy enough to be a prop.

He is essentially a third prop for the Storm.


Oates is a winger because his build is not currently ready to even play in the back row let alone the middle.

Oates is a completely different person and does not help your point.

 

[upthebroncs]

Anyone who thinks lock is the same as a prop has no clue.

Anyone that cannot see that coaches tactically use the lock position as a third prop on the field has no clue

 

[Foordy]

He plays in the middle every week as a lock.

He is built like a middle forward.

He is tall enough and heavy enough to be a prop.

He is essentially a third prop for the Storm.


Oates is a winger because his build is not currently ready to even play in the back row let alone the middle.

Oates is a completely different person and does not help your point.

Then you should have qualified your statement that being bigger and taller doesn't than McGuire only makes you a better prop than him in certain circumstances

 

[upthebroncs]

Then you should have qualified your statement that being bigger and taller doesn't than McGuire only makes you a better prop than him in certain circumstances

McGuire has played prop for most of his career.

You people know who Finucane is and to say he's not built like a prop and can't play prop is a joke.

I never said it made him better than McGuire? I just used McGuire as a comparison to say that Finucane can play Prop.

 

[ivanhungryjak]

Anyone who thinks lock is the same as a prop has no clue.

Oh no, not this old chestnut again ...

 

[Taylor1921]

So

Anyone that cannot see that coaches tactically use the lock position as a third prop on the field has no clue

Taumalolo does not play like a prop? Wtf is your point?

 

[upthebroncs]

So

Taumalolo does not play like a prop? Wtf is your point?

Pfft.. Taumalolo plays like Taumalolo. Noone else in the game plays like him.

At 191cm tall and over 110kgs. He has the dimensions to play prop.

 

[upthebroncs]

I'm not going to argue what a Lock is because it's up to the coaches interpretation.

 

[BroncsFan]

No he did not, he was off the bench majority or at lock. Tolman, Kasiano and Graham were the props.

Sorry do they not have props on the bench... he was playing in the middle for 30-40 minutes a game off the bench.

Didn't realise every team only had 2 props because they can only wear 8 or 10.